Monday, October 11, 2021

The lie of multiculturalism for Columbus Day

Is best displayed in this, that popped up on a history Facebook page I follow:


You see that?  I hope this is fake and no actual Indian ever said this.  But if it's genuine, then Indians were ... perfect.  Without sin.  Never did anything wrong.  Wonderful.  Fabulous.  Better than Jesus.   Just like those Bushmen in The Gods Must Be Crazy.  There simply was no sin, evil or wrongdoing before Europeans came to the lands. So says this meme that strongly suggests it's the opinion of an American Indian. 

Which is stupid, wrong, a lie and false.  Indian culture was like any and all cultures.  It had plenty of wars, genocide, slavery, imperialism, conquest, thieving, wrong doing and politicking that would make Machiavelli blush.  Just like all tribes and cultures and kingdoms and nations since the beginning of time. 

Multiculturalism was supposed to teach us Western children of Western Imperialism what the world was really like.  It functioned under two basic premises. One, that us Americans (and Westerners in general) never knew Western culture did anything wrong or bad.  Two, our views of the world were skewed because of our racist imperialism imposing our ideas of the world on the world instead of seeing the world from its own vantage point.

Therefore, there were two solutions.  First, emphasize, perhaps over emphasize (can you really overemphasize?), the sins of America and the West to wake people up to our own imperfections and egregious sins.  And second, allow other cultures to tell us just what their cultures and civilizations were really like. 

On the surface, the first solution doesn't appear terrible.  Repentance and admitting to sin is a very Christian, and hence Western virtue, as long as it is done with the correct purpose in mind.  The second was a problem from the beginning.  It should be obvious that simply asking American Indians or Hindus or Africans or Japanese or Muslims or any people in the world about their own culture might actually meet with the same skewed or dishonest picture that Americans were supposed to have.  Especially since cultural repentance and admitting ancestral and cultural sin is not a universal trait. 

But so it was, and so it is.  When my son had a cultural anthropology class, the line was already moved from my anthropology classes in college.  Back then, it was 'who are we to judge?'  In fairness, that was also how we were told to look at our own sins: the Inquisition, the Witch Hunts, Slavery.  We condemn the sins but not the sinners.  

Today, we condemn the sins and sinners of the West, and go beyond simply not judging the sins of the rest of the world to almost embracing them.  In my day, we said human sacrifice or infanticide or child sacrifice were bad, but we don't judge the Aztecs or the Celts or the Native Americans who did such things.  In my son's class, they don't even know why we're fussing.  After all, in their course the question of human sacrifice itself is up for debate.  We know Global Warming is the threat of the ages and too many people are causing the world to die.  Therefore, it's perfectly acceptable to look at those Aztecs or Celts and think they may have been on to something when it comes to population control. So said his class's discussion.  

Because we know from Multiculturalism, if it ain't Western, it's good.  We know this because people from those cultures are happy to say so.  Likewise, the idea that those things like child sacrifice or terminating the weak and sickly were bad comes from old white Western, Christian ideals.  And we know those were always and altogether bad.  Therefore, it's time to give sacrificing the baby to the fires a second look.  After all, if the worst civilization in history - Western that is - said it was bad, there might be something to it after all!

Happy Columbus Indigenous Peoples Day.  Celebrated not despite the savagery and barbarism of those non-Western cultures, but increasingly because of them. 

11 comments:

  1. The Left believe the truth is so important that they have to lie about in order for us to believe it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I find that if you removed the lies, the Left would be like a body without bones.

      Delete
  2. I'm fairly certain horses were extinct in the Americas before the Spaniards arrived. That's one of the reasons Cortez conquered the Aztecs so easily. The reference to horses in that meme should be the first red flag. The fact that Cortez had thousands of local natives helping him slaughter the Aztecs should also tell you something.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When I was in college, there were still a few who clung to that post-war early multicultural bilge that nobody in the Western Hemisphere had even heard of war or wrongdoing - much like the goofy meme above. It was starting to fade, since the overwhelming archeological evidence, even if interpreted in the best light possible, showed cultures of war and defense and conquest. And that was in the North American areas, not even the Aztecs and Incas who you couldn't deny their savagery. Now I don't think they admire their cultures despite their savagery or in denial of it, but increasingly I think they do because of it.

      Delete
  3. Pithy remark overheard:

    "Indigenous people" are the next-to-last people to conquer a territory.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Heh. That is now my favorite retort to the so popular Indigenous People day.

      Delete
  4. Western myth of the Noble Savage. Criminals among Indians were exiled from the tribes or executed. Minor offenses could be taken care of by paying agreed compensation. Most tribes had strong concepts of private personal property and woe betide those who stole. Familial groups tended to look out for each other, with outsiders lucky if they were not plundered and murdered with rape thrown in if the outsider was female, unless she was kept as a slave for the tribe. Mention has already been made of the Europeans bringing horses. Almost all tribes had some concept of money as a means of exchange. Indians, like all people at all times, had their virtues and their vices, often differing from tribe to tribe. Western Leftists reduce them into stick figures to belabor their own societies.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm blessed with a wife who is both descendant of Indians (her great grandmother being full blood Native American) and also Jenny Wiley, a woman whose family was kidnapped and murdered by the Indians who took her into slavery until she escaped. So her family has had an even approach to the subject.

      Delete
    2. I see the McClarey's have a dog.

      Delete
  5. It's summed up pretty well in this clip: https://youtu.be/EQALILzth70?t=121

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There are so many reasons that would not be able to be made today. More's the pity.

      Delete

Let me know your thoughts