That is, just another annoying blip in the noisy static. Apparently he produced a docuseries called The United States and the Holocaust. If the interview in this article is any indicator, it is the same old same old for many, especially young, Americans.
That is, he's gracious enough to say the United States wasn't exactly responsible for the Holocaust per se, but then proceeds to explain how the United States and Nazi Germany were practically salt and pepper. He trots out the Jim Crow era, genocide, Native Americans, slavery and antisemitism charges, applied to one country as easily as to the other.
Apparently at least one episode focuses on the rift between FDR and antisemite Charles Lindberg. I asked my son, who recently graduated college, about that. He told me that those of his peers who even had heard of Lindberg, only knew him as some Nazi hero in our Nazi country, vaguely aware that he did something with flying.
In keeping with our era of hyper-judgmentalism, the series seems wrapped in the context of 'sure we beat the Nazis, liberated the camps, and allowed thousands to come into our country ... but we didn't do it perfectly enough.' Not like it would have been if our generation was there! When you have the track record we have, I suppose arrogance is all that's left.
The funny part of this interview is that one of the producers seems to think they've really blown the lid off of something. The person talks about how 'uncomfortable' the real truth of our nation and its role in those events makes people in the audience feel, once they see the production. Really? That's like saying people will be uncomfortable when they learn the secret that slavery existed in America's past. That's as much a lack of awareness as you can get.
Years ago, when I used to comment on the Huffington Post, I ran into people who believed that the whole of the Holocaust was an American conspiracy, as was the entire war. By then (c. 2004ish), it wasn't uncommon to run into people online who believed the Nazis were lifted up by the American Military Industrial complex for the sole purpose of inciting a war that the US could then exploit, and use to subjugate the world to our racist, imperialist ways. Compared to them, the saner ones back then dismissed such thinking, being content with the notion that America was no better than the Nazis, and didn't really lift them up as much as inspire them (the old 'the Nazis became racist when they studied the Confederacy' storyline).
That was almost 20 years ago. Does Mr. Burns really think people like that have gone away as opposed to multiplied exponentially? Does he really believe they will be uncomfortable with his documentary? About the only thing that will make them uncomfortable is his insistence that the US isn't solely responsible for the Holocaust. That might bother them a bit.
I don't think we realize just how post-Western, and by extension post-American, we already are. Harkening back to my oldest son, he said a cool 1/3 of his classmates can barely distinguish between the Swastika and the Stars and Stripes. Had I not seen examples myself of such thinking over the years, I'd almost be inclined to think he exaggerates. But I have.
And we have those useful fools like Burns, a historian I've traditionally enjoyed, to thank. Because instead of seeing the bleeding obvious, they think they are bravely facing the fan club by exclusively focusing on the negative, endlessly criticizing, and so blurring the line between Nazis and America.
BTW, all of this is made possible by the Left effectively elevating Western-based racism as the only, all defining, most evil, unpardonable sin in the world. And that goes for anything we thought we did well, like win the Second World War. This is aided by the fact that by now, about 75% of our recollection of WWII is focused on the Holocaust, primarily as it effected Jewish (and sometimes homosexual) victims; about 10% focused on the Japanese interment camps* in the US, another 10% recalling the use of the Atomic Bombs, over 4% (but growing) the segregation in the US military in WWII, and a shrinking less than 1% on D-Day.
For most youngsters today, that was WWII. The tens of millions of others killed barely make a drop in the bucket where focus is concerned. The soldiers? Except for some minority groups, they are barely mentioned at this point. I subscribe the the National Veterans Memorial and Museum updates. It's been many moons since a white male veteran was showcased. You could be forgiven for not knowing white men ever served in our military if you got your info from that museum.
But then, when mentioned at all, it's increasingly the fact that they were likely racists in their own white supremacist army. Hence Burns can acknowledge 'a little heroism' from that time, but those were mere specks of light in the overall darkness that is, and always has been, America. When that's your narrative, it's not hard for young people to conclude the Soviets might have been the good guys all along.
*In December 2021, I saw on the news that some Asian American activists are wanting 'Pearl Harbor Remembrance Day' to be replaced by the anniversary of the Japanese Internment camps. Sort of how Juneteenth will assuredly never be used to replace July 4th. Again, we're seeing the utter destruction of the West and America, and it's likely a bit too late to stop it. Thanks go brilliant thinkers like Burns.
The other week I mentioned something about Charles Lindbergh to a friend of mine (in his 30's) only to find out that he had no idea who he was. I guess that's better than thinking he was a Nazi sleeper agent or something, but still pretty shameful.
ReplyDeleteThe Nazi accusations have always mystified me in a way, considering how many times Lindbergh rails against Nazism in his journals. Similarly people will say "but he didn't fight on the western front!" which ignores the point that FDR forbid the Air Force from reinstating him, and he STILL got involved in the war by acting as an "advisor" on the pacific front. But on the other hand it doesn't, since his solution was "it would be best if the communist Russians and Nazi Germans took each other out without us getting involved." Of course anyone who opposes communism will be tarred as an enemy of the state, especially when he opposed the beloved FDR.
Meanwhile the man not only flew over the pacific, but was instrumental in developing commercial air travel, co-invented the perfusion pump that allowed heart surgeries, was a devoted conservationist, and was a staunch advocate for the preservation of world cultures. Yet all we can do is despise him.
Minor correction: Technically Lindbergh was prevented from re-enlisting in the Army, as the Air Force wasn't a separate branch until after WWII.
DeleteMeanwhile the man not only flew over the pacific, but was instrumental in developing commercial air travel, co-invented the perfusion pump that allowed heart surgeries, was a devoted conservationist, and was a staunch advocate for the preservation of world cultures. Yet all we can do is despise him.
DeleteCommented on this the other day to my preacher. Something I've seen several times online - in large and small ways both - that it doesn't matter how much you do with your life or how long it is, that apparently the rule is now you are only ever as good as the worst moment of your life - no matter how short or fleeting it was.
We have no need of Satan any longer, social media has allowed all of us to be the Accuser.
Imagine if God was like the media when it came to our sins?
DeleteBob, I thank God every day He is not.
DeleteOne problem is that the Left has made racism into the only true sin, a monolith, unforgivable and all defining. Drop the N-Word in a 20 year old email or take over Germany and murder millions of ethnic minorities. You're now just a racist. Cure cancer and bring peace to the Middle East, but make an off color joke 12 years ago? You're now just a racist. And that is all you'll ever be. Hence almost every aspect of the West and America can be dismantled because it isn't hard to find racism, especially based on today's definitions. And once found, there is no redemption, only eradication. It's history the way Stalin would do it, and the only thing shocking is how many are embracing it, and how many more are turning a blind eye.
DeleteI saw someone online the other day seriously argue "the germans were never put in internment camps like the japanese were!" Or when I discovered there's a lot of debate and investigation on America's dropping of leaflets over Japan warning of the incoming bomb attacks. Because apparently anything other countries do must have all the nuance applied on how they weren't really that bad - while anything the West does must have every effort to prove how awful it was.
ReplyDeleteYou can find some relief when you realize that - as ever - it's all about power. It's not about ethics or morality, that's just what they say to dupe useful idiots like Mark Shea or Ken Burns into furthering the cause. In reality it is all about power. Hence the whole "queers for palastine" hilarity - it's all about that which supports or brings down the Western civilizations and gets power into their hands. What you're noticing Dave isn't a bug, it's the feature. It's not an unintended consequence, but very much an intended one.
My son had to correct his professor about that. It was during the 'Asian American genocide in America!' wave that hit back when President Biden said he would get to the bottom of Covid. My son's professor said straight out that we only put Japanese Americans in camps, which proves our racism toward Asians. My son had to correct him - though he did it privately, which I think was proper (I admit if he did it publicly, it would make sure the others heard it as well). I wondered how you could get a PhD and not know that. Then I look at most history from historians born after about the mid-70s, and it's not hard to see. By now, it's not the history that is taught, but the activism. Which frequently requires ignoring mountains of inconvenient facts. And since universities are increasingly homogenous in their ideologies and goals, there's nobody to call them out.
DeleteAnd yes, it's about power. It's about Globalization. The need to eradicate the West and American Experiment. Which is happening so fast I think we don't quite realize how quickly things are going to unfold.
Ken Burns is just another member of our imbecile ruling class, faithfully regurgitating the current party line. To Sheol with the whole worthless lot of them.
ReplyDeleteI'd say the ruling class has solidified its hold on the key institutions i our society. As a result, there's not much dissent at this point among those who want to suck up to the good graces of our elites.
DeleteIt's a shame what happened to Burns. He's now just a Zeitgeist Riefenstahl, a videographic pusher of the approved narratives, only without the talent.
ReplyDeleteThe bright spot, if you can call it that, is that the constant corrosive attitude towards truth--oft hard-wrung, belatedly-acknowledged, etc--will devour the regime's "truths" as well.
But the costs: "the Gods of the Copybook Headings, with fire and terror return."
He joins a growing fraternity of court prophets, throwing it all out the window and hoping to keep up with the latest. It's a shame, because back in the day I appreciated his contributions. I fear that will be a growing lament in the years to come.
Delete