This:
As seen on the Stumbling Toward Heaven blog |
The thing hurting the proclamation of the Gospel most, at least in the dying West, is that up and coming youngsters just don't believe it. Oh, they've heard the story most of their lives. At least in the vaguest sense, filtered through the opinions and research of critics, skeptics and people hostile to the Faith. Shocking no one, they just don't believe it. Our atheist culture has told them the Christian Faith is worth no more than a Grimm's Fairy Tale at best, and the Marxist inspired Liberation Theology tradition can't get enough of pointing out how wretched and evil and racist and phobic sexist those old pages of "Holy" Scripture are. The constant drumbeat among believers and leaders today of repenting for the first 2000 years of the Faith, and willingness to change on a dime when the World snaps its fingers, only plays into this.
Plus, as has been said for years, many youngsters just don't believe anyone believes it anymore. I've quoted many times that youth from ages ago who I first saw mentioned at Catholic and Enjoying It. Why are youth formally rejecting belief in God and the Gospel and Jesus Christ? Because they don't see anyone acting like they believe it's true. Oh, on Sundays you get angels and demons and miracles and God and all. But come Monday, and light can barely shine through the gap between the Christian and the Atheist in how life in this world is approached. As someone quipped in a discussion some time back, the big difference between atheists and Christians today is that atheists can sleep in on Sunday.
So there are few things worse in this hot mess context than admitting our faith and prayers and even God are utterly worthless unless they align with the actual solutions to our problems in the form of our political activism for the real world. That tells these young people all they need to know to conclude that yes, Virginia, religion is dead. Or at least pointless. Politics and the state are all that matter. The here and now counts, since there is nothing else. And obviously material solutions are the only ones of consequence. Why, you have plenty of good churchgoers who admit it. See Mark's bold claims above. When the guy who drags himself out of bed to show up to church on Sunday is willing to admit just how useless all this God and prayer garbage is next to our real world solutions, do you really think what goes on in that church is worth anything to our increasingly secularized youth? I don't think so.
And it's not just Mark and the godless secularists who claim that the efficacy of our prayers to God is contingent upon their adherence to proper political activism. A staggering number of Christians and leaders, not just Catholic, have jumped on this 'God as a bad joke' bandwagon, even if they don't realize it. And not just with gun control. Sadly, nothing appears to help secular evangelism today more than modern Christianity. More's the pity.
Oh, and we won't delve into Mark attributing those turning to prayer's fruitfulness and God's sovereignty to the designs of the devil since it doesn't align with his political opinions. That makes me think of no other passage in Scripture than this:
But when the Pharisees heard it they said, “It is only by Beel′zebul, the prince of demons, that this man casts out demons.” Knowing their thoughts, Jesus said to them, “Every kingdom divided against itself is laid waste, and no city or house divided against itself will stand; and if Satan casts out Satan, he is divided against himself; how then will his kingdom stand? And if I cast out demons by Beel′zebul, by whom do your sons cast them out? Therefore, they shall be your judges. But if it is by the Spirit of God that I cast out demons, then the kingdom of God has come upon you. Or how can one enter a strong man’s house and plunder his goods, unless he first binds the strong man? Then indeed he may plunder his house. He who is not with me is against me, and he who does not gather with me scatters. Therefore, I tell you, every sin and blasphemy will be forgiven men, but the blasphemy against the Spirit will not be forgiven. And whoever says a word against the Son of man will be forgiven; but whoever speaks against the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven, either in this age or in the age to come.
I realize there is a lot of theology in that passage, but sometimes a superficial reading is enough to jar our senses. Don't attribute appeals to God's providence to Satan. Unless Pope Francis and others are correct when they allude to the possibility that, like almost anything else in the history of the Faith, the whole 'eternal separation from God' is a bunch of bunk, you might want to slow down associating the working of God and his children with the Devil for any reason, much less political ones. Prayers for his soul being in order in this case.
Hard not to look at that cartoon and go, "huh - so I don't need to bother invoking the saints or Mary then either."
ReplyDeleteI don't know if he still is approaching it that way, but back in the day when he glommed onto this secular approach, he made sure not to belittle the thoughts and prayers, but simply judged the thoughts and motives of those saying so. Invoking the gift of judging all who question leftwing activism. I didn't see that as much in this post, with that cartoon being what he spoke against back in the day.
DeleteIs there a recommended alternative to “thoughts and prayers” then? I mean, most of us can’t do much about things far away from us but think of those involved and pray.
ReplyDeleteI fear the problem with those who follow such secular activism is that they get painted into corners. The whole 'mock those stupid thoughts and prayers to that loser fairy tale God' was driven initially by openly secular and atheist activists and commentators. Naturally for them it's a waste. But as believers jump on board, you begin getting into the problems you mention. Though for them, failure to conform to the obvious solutions are a form of 'what I have failed to do' level of sin.
DeleteThe Devil: "True virtue is to become defenseless against your enemies by laying down your weapons". Mark agrees with the Devil.
ReplyDeleteHe is one who openly mocks those dunderheads who speak of bearing arms against a future day when our government could turn pure Nazi evil. Which always makes me wonder. It 's as if people like Mark are saying flat out that if the worst happens, you can count on them to do nothing to stop it. It makes me think of yet another quotable from my sons: Sometimes what passes for Christian virtue is merely cowardice with a Jesus mask.
Delete(Tom New Poster)
DeleteDave, I don't think it's real cowardice, just blind stupidity. Guys like Shea are like the suburban "pacifists" of 1930s England who annoyed trench-veteran CS Lewis, or perhaps more like middle-school kids who giggle during disaster drills: they don't really believe such a horror would come to pass; . Of course, some of the "dunderheads" he criticizes proved real dunderheads in the past, jumping at false alarms like "Red Scares" or civil protests against racism in the 1960s, but he should know the difference. In my experience, ideologues scream loudest and most outrageously when then need to drown out the sound of a hated opponent saying what the ideologue knows or fears is true.