Tuesday, October 24, 2023

Like the lost tales from another world

Is what I thought of when I saw the tragic story of a woman stabbed to death in Detroit.  She was Jewish, and was Synagogue president.  From the beginning, the police have stated there is no clear motive behind the killing.  This latest article, from the Detroit Free Press, reports that the police are still saying there is no evidence that antisemitism was behind the attack.  

There is nothing at all wrong with this.  In a sane, pre-insanity of the Obama era world, this is how the press and the police handle it.  Before the dark ages of the Hate Crime era.  A human being has been slain.  We leave it at mourning, regret, prayers for the victim and family, and hope for justice. We are still gathering information and not leaping to conclusions.  Motives are not know, and are not speculated about.  Nothing else is being linked to it.  Nothing about antisemitism on a national stage, or even across Detroit.  No groups of people are suspect.  Again, like a time capsule from the age of sanity.

Of course we know why.  Multiple attacks and crimes against the Jewish community have happened since the beginning of the Israeli-Hamas war.  Twice Hamas has called upon global outrage and demonstrations.  Protests erupted immediately after the worst slaughter of Jews since the Holocaust.  While some were fine and peaceful, a staggering number - including around college campuses across the West - cheered what Hamas did, with some calling for more (that is, slaughter of Israelis).  And some Palestinian and pro-Palestinian protesters, along with BLM outlets and leftwing socialists, made it clear seeing more of what Hamas did in that first attack was wanted and demanded.  A few went so far as adding variations on 'Gas the Jews' to make sure we see it's not just because of Israel or Israelis, but because of Jew hate.  And all from not white, not MAGA, not GOP, not Red State, not Christian, not conservative types. 

Hence the sudden wave of 'let's not be hasty' where attacks on synagogues, Jewish individuals, and even murderers of Jews are concerned.  Again, absolutely nothing wrong with this level of restraint from law enforcement, the Jewish community, the ADL, and the press.  It's how it should be done.  There is, however, everything wrong with why they are suddenly doing it this way, and not the way we've seen for the last too many years.  

That is, immediately implying hate crime, saturating the press with stories of increased hate crimes against the Jewish community and all minorities, impugning rightwing and conservative types as antisemitic white nationalists who are to blame, and making sure to drudge up yet another wave of stories bringing up Nazis, Germany, antisemitism in the West, the Church's history, bigotry among white Christians, America as a 400 year slave state, and virtually anything to do with the sins of the last thousand years of Western civilization. 

The worst thing is, it isn't just the worst slaughter of Jews since the Holocaust that is causing this sudden shift in coverage.  It's because of who slaughtered the Jews and who has made it clear they're willing to support more of the same.  That's the bad part.  It breaks the sacred narrative of the modern Left.  And no amount of slaughtering or protecting Jews will ever be more important to modern progressivism than defending that all important - and demonstrably false - narrative. 

2 comments:

  1. The willful blindness or refusal to see reality as it is, is evil. But it's still shocking to me that so many in the media willfully ignore, give the benefit of the doubt, or simply gloss over the actions of those who explicitly express the will to violence. That's a level of commitment to a reality that you wish something to be, but is not, that is stupid at best and demonic at worst. Either way it leads to hell.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think demonic is fair. We've seen it before Of course. Racist slurs against black conservatives. Sexist tirades against women challenging transgender activism. Attacking women who inconveniently accused liberal Democrats of sexual misconduct. Even antisemitism delivered from leftwing activism (though it was usually swept under the carpet), such as Occupy Wall Street. What sets this apart is that it was so horrific, and immediately met with cheers from Palestinians in various locations, along with leftwing activists and various non-white (think BLM) outlets. And in some cases, making it clear it's about the killing of Jews, not just going after Israel. It obviously caught the Left/Media off guard, but didn't take long for them to adjust. Mostly make it about generic antisemitism, mention Nazi Germany, then talk of Hamas and Israel as partners in crime and ignore the obvious. Bonus points if you can bring it back to Western oppression and imperialism. And for an extra dose of caution, like this tragic event, exercise a restraint we've not seen in many moons from our authorities and media outlets.

      Delete

Let me know your thoughts