|We judge. We condemn.|
He's mean. He's cruel. He's a zealot. He's a witch hunter who doesn't seems to believe a rip of it, but revels in the power to torture and maim and kill. He appears to take unholy delight in watching Isaac squirm under his feet, as he first tells him that Rebecca, Isaac's daughter, has been burned at the stake, then tells him she is to be burned unless a champion can be found (I'll leave the gentle reader to figure out just who the champion will be). In short, he's what most people outside of the Catholic Church (and a few within the Church) envision when they reflect on what Catholicism is all about.
When I was a pastor, I used to tell my congregations to avoid living up to negative stereotypes. I realize there really isn't anything you can do about stereotypes. People will develop them and apply them, usually to groups they don't like. Still, you can try to avoid living up to them. Therefore, when it comes to reflecting on what the world thinks about Catholicism, consider this: don't rush to condemn. I don't mean we shouldn't look at things, or call a spade a spade. It doesn't mean we can't call good what it is, or evil what it is. It doesn't mean we shouldn't pray for justice. It does mean we should exercise restraint. We should avoid the appearance of little inquisitor wannabes. Even if we know in our guts someone is guilty; even if we know, for instance, that three police officers causing the death of a young man with Down Syndrome is an appalling and inexcusable breach of professional responsibility at best, we should still wait and see what the facts of the case actually are.
And no, we can't just appeal to the media's accounts of what happened. That would be the media that has gone a long way in convincing the world that anyone who thinks about the Catholic Church should envision this image:
As Catholics we should pray for the victim and the victim's family and loved ones. We should pray that justice is done, and that God grant peace to the families of those who were party to this man's death. We should expect proper payment to be made, jail time if it is deemed appropriate, termination from the job, whatever. Or, if the facts should emerge, innocence. But what we shouldn't do is jump on the bandwagon and sound as if we have the word of the inerrant media, and it's time to poll-vault over all the due process and evidence garbage and get straight to the execution. Good for aiding anti-Catholic stereotypes, bad for actually being about the presence of Christ in the world.